Testing methods - Overview of black-box & gray-box testing

 Testing Methods  

Software testing methods are conducted by testers with the aim of ensuring that all features of the system operate correctly according to the requirements of the customer or end users. There are three basic software testing methods: white-box testing, black-box testing, and gray-box testing.

In the previous session, we learned about the white-box testing method. Now it's time to move on to the other two testing methods.

1. Black-box testing

What is the black-box testing?

Black-box testing is a software testing method that focuses on testing the functionality of an application without needing to know its internal structure or source code. In this approach, testers are only concerned with the inputs and outputs of the system to determine whether the functionality operates correctly, without considering how it works internally. Black-box testing is similar to inspecting a black box, where you only observe the input and output transformations without knowing anything about the internal workings.

Types of black-box testing

This software testing method includes the following types:

• All-pairs testing
• Model-based testing
• Boundary value analysis
• Equivalence partitioning
• Specification-based testing
• Traceability matrix
• Exploratory testing

Advantages and disadvantages of white-box testing

Advantages: 

• Independence from Internal Implementation: Testers do not need knowledge of the internal code structure, making it easier to perform testing without access to the source code. 
• Simulates User Perspective: Black-box testing simulates real-world usage scenarios, allowing testers to evaluate the software from the perspective of end users. 
• Encourages Diverse Testing Approaches: Testers can focus solely on inputs and outputs, leading to diverse testing approaches that can uncover various types of defects. 
• Early Detection of Defects: It can identify issues early in the software development lifecycle, helping to address them before they escalate into more critical problems. 
• Supports Parallel Development: Black-box testing can be conducted concurrently with development, allowing for faster feedback and iteration cycles. 

Disadvantages: 

• Limited Test Coverage: Since testers do not have visibility into the internal code structure, it may be challenging to achieve comprehensive test coverage, potentially missing certain defects. 
• Inability to Identify Root Causes: Black-box testing may uncover defects without providing insights into the underlying causes, making it difficult to debug and resolve issues efficiently. 
• Repetitive Testing: Test cases may need to be repeated across multiple versions or iterations of the software, leading to redundancy and increased testing effort. 
• Difficulty in Error Localization: Identifying the exact location of defects within the codebase can be challenging, as testers rely solely on observed behaviors rather than internal logic. 
• Limited Structural Insight: Black-box testing may overlook structural flaws or vulnerabilities within the software, which could be critical for security or performance testing.

2. Gray-box Testing

What is the gray-box testing?

Grey-box testing is a software testing method that combines elements of both white-box and black-box testing. In grey-box testing, testers have some information about the internal structure or design of the application but do not possess complete details. This allows them to have a holistic view of the system's nature while maintaining independence and objectivity similar to black-box testing.

In grey-box testing, testers can leverage the information they have about the internal structure to design more effective test cases and diversify testing methods. This helps enhance the ability to detect errors and minimize risks during the testing process.

In summary, grey-box testing is a fusion of white-box and black-box testing, enabling testers to utilize some information about the internal structure of the application to design more effective test cases.

Advantages and disadvantages of white-box testing

Advantages:

• Combining methods: Grey-box testing combines both white-box and black-box testing, leveraging the advantages of both approaches.
• Enhanced error detection capability: By utilizing information about the internal structure, grey-box testing can design more effective test cases, aiding in the detection of errors that black-box testing might overlook.
• Focus on critical areas: Testers can use structural information to concentrate testing on critical or higher-risk areas within the application.
  
• Risk reduction: By utilizing some information about the internal structure, grey-box testing can minimize risks during the testing process compared to black-box testing.
  

Disadvantages:

• Limitation in accessing internal structure: Gray-box testing may not provide full access to the internal structure of the software, which can limit the depth of testing compared to white-box testing.
• Complexity in test case design: Designing effective test cases for gray-box testing can be more challenging than black-box testing, as testers need to balance the use of structural information with maintaining independence from internal implementation.
• Dependency on available information: The effectiveness of gray-box testing heavily relies on the quantity and quality of available information about the internal structure of the software. Limited or incomplete information can hinder the testing process.
• Difficulty in maintaining test cases: As the internal structure of the software changes over time, maintaining and updating gray-box test cases can become complex and time-consuming compared to black-box testing.

Depending on the specific project requirements and circumstances, testing methods can be used independently or in combination to ensure the quality and reliability of the software.

Hau.Vo
....................................
Source: istqb.org